By Ben Jones, Partner and Head of Commercial and Property Litigation
If I had a pound for every time someone told me, "It's just a boundary dispute," I would probably have retired by now. After nearly two decades dealing with property and commercial disputes, I have learned that boundary disputes between neighbours are rarely about a fence, hedge or strip of land. Those are simply the visible symptoms. The real issue is often much more human.
Boundary disputes can arise in many different ways, including disagreements over fences, hedges, rights of way, access tracks, agricultural boundaries, encroachments or the position of a boundary shown on historic plans. Each case turns on its own facts, including the title documents, historic use of the land, physical features on the ground and the conduct of previous owners.
Usually, by the time a matter reaches my team, the parties have already gone through months, and sometimes years, of frustration. Communication has broken down. Assumptions have been made. Positions have hardened. And what might have started as a relatively minor disagreement has become a matter of principle.
I often tell clients that neighbour disputes are unique because, unlike many other forms of litigation, the legal outcome is only part of the solution. Most commercial litigants never have to look across the garden fence at one another after their case concludes. Neighbours generally do. That reality shapes how our Commercial and Property Litigation Team approach every dispute.
When a Few Feet Becomes a Fortune
One matter that has always stayed with me involved a disagreement over a relatively modest piece of land. At first glance, the disputed area appeared to have very little value. Yet both parties were prepared to spend significant sums arguing about it.
As we worked through the matter, it became apparent that neither side was really motivated by the land itself. The disagreement had become linked to years of perceived slights, misunderstandings and frustrations. The legal issue was merely the latest chapter in a much longer story.
Sadly, this is far from unusual.
I have acted in disputes involving access tracks, agricultural boundaries, rights of way and encroachments where the emotional investment vastly exceeded the financial value of the land in question.
That does not mean those disputes are unimportant, quite the opposite. Property ownership matters deeply to all of us. It is often tied to memories, livelihoods, family history and often our sense of identity.
What it does mean is that solving the dispute requires a broader perspective than simply determining who is technically right.
Boundaries Are Not Always Black and White
Many clients are surprised when I explain that the answer to a boundary dispute is not always found neatly on a Land Registry title plan. People understandably assume there must be a definitive line recorded somewhere.
Unfortunately, it is rarely that simple.
I have been involved in disputes where the relevant documents dated back decades, where historic physical features had disappeared, or where different generations of owners had simply treated the land differently over time. The law provides a framework for resolving those uncertainties, but there is often no instant answer. In many cases, understanding the history of a property is just as important as understanding the legal documents.
Why Trust in Expertise Matters
One aspect of my role that I particularly enjoy is bringing together different areas of expertise across the firm. From my client's perspective, the dispute may appear straightforward. Behind the scenes, however, resolving it often requires a much broader understanding of property ownership and land use.
Neighbour disputes often begin as litigation matters, but they rarely remain exclusively within the litigation team. An issue involving a boundary may require input from our residential or commercial property lawyers who deal with land transactions and title issues every day. A dispute concerning rural land may benefit from the experience of colleagues who regularly advise farmers, estates and landowners. Planning considerations can sometimes become relevant, in which case I may find myself liaising with professional colleagues from land agency and surveying practices. Inherited property can bring private client and probate issues into play.
One of the advantages of working within a full-service regional law firm is being able to draw on that collective experience when advising clients.
Court is Not Always the Best Outcome in a Neighbour Dispute
People are sometimes surprised when I say that some of my most successful outcomes are cases that never reach Court. That is not because we shy away from litigation. When court proceedings are necessary, we pursue them robustly. However, litigation should be a means to an end, not an objective in itself. The best outcome is often the one that resolves the underlying problem while allowing everybody to move forward. Sometimes that means mediation. Sometimes it means a carefully negotiated agreement. Sometimes it means helping a client understand that while they may have a strong legal argument, the practical and financial realities point towards a different solution.
The older I get, the more I appreciate the value of that practical perspective.
Looking Beyond the Fence
Perhaps the biggest lesson I have learned from dealing with neighbour disputes is that people rarely seek legal advice simply because of a fence, a hedge or a disputed line on a plan. They seek advice because they want certainty, reassurance and a route forward.
My role is not simply to explain what the law says. It is to help clients navigate a difficult situation and arrive at a solution that makes sense for them. Sometimes that requires robust litigation. Often it requires careful negotiation. Almost always it requires a degree of perspective.
After all, the fence is rarely the real problem.
How We Can Help
Blanchards Bailey’s Commercial and Property Litigation Team advises clients on boundary disputes, right of way, access issues, encroachments and other neighbour disputes.
We help our clients to review the legal position, consider the evidence, advise on practical options and, when possible, work towards a resolution that avoids unnecessary escalation.
If you are dealing with a boundary or neighbour dispute and would like to understand your options, please contact Ben Jones at 01258 483597, or request a callback to speak with our team.
Locations: Blandford, Dorchester, Shaftesbury, Weymouth.
You can also visit our Property Disputes and Litigation and Disputes Resolution pages on our website for more information. View Ben's verified client reviews on ReviewSolicitors.
So, how can we help?
Whatever your requirements, our team is standing by.
Call us today on
01258 459361