Is Special Guardianship an Alternative to Adoption in the UK?

By Julie Keogh, Senior Family Law Executive.

In family law, one of the most important legal developments has been the move away from treating parenthood as a collection of rights.  The focus now sits on parental responsibility, a statutory concept that centres on the authority, duties and decision-making needed to protect and raise a child under the Children Act 1989. 

For kinship carers such as grandparents, aunts, uncles, siblings and close family friends, that point matters in daily life. It shapes decisions about school, healthcare, travel, social services and contact with birth parents.  When disagreement arises, the question is rarely abstract.  It is about who can make a decision, when they can make it, and where that authority ends.   In this article, we explore the key differences between these two responsibilities. 

Parental Responsibility: What It Really Means

Section 3(1) of the Children Act 1989 defines parental responsibility as all the rights, duties, powers, responsibilities and authority that a parent has in relation to a child and the child’s property. In practical terms, that covers decisions about education, medical treatment, religion, care arrangements and legal representation. 

The mother automatically has parental responsibility for a child. The father does if he was married to the mother at the time of birth, or he is named on the birth certificate (for births registered after 1 December 2003).   Parental responsibility can be acquired, either by agreement or through the court, by unmarried fathers, same-sex partners, guardians and step-parents. 

For kinship carers, the main point is simple.  Kinship carers do not automatically acquire parental responsibility. Parental responsibility can be shared, but it is not casually handled over in the way day-to-day care often is.  A child may spend time with a school, nursery or childminder, yet the person who holds parental responsibility remains legally responsible for key decisions and the child’s welfare overall.

Why Special Guardianship Exists

Special Guardianship Orders (SGOs) were introduced to fill the gap. They sit between long-term fostering and adoption, offering more permanence than foster care without creating the complete legal break from the birth family that adoption brings. 

That structure is especially relevant in kinship care. It can give a child long-term stability and a clear legal framework, while still preserving family ties with their birth family.  In some situations, that balance is a better fit for the child’s history, identity, relationships or cultural background than adoption would be. 

The Key Advantage of an SGO: Enhanced Parental Responsibility

The defining legal strength of a Special Guardianship Order is the enhanced parental responsibility it gives to the special guardian. Under section 14C of the Children Act 1989, a special guardian may exercise parental responsibility to the exclusion of any other person who also has parental responsibility, except another special guardian.

This is a significant distinction.   Someone named in a Child Arrangements Order as the person with whom the child lives may also have parental responsibility, but they do not gain the same overriding authority. In practice, an SGO often gives the kinship carer the final say on most day-to-day matters and on many larger decisions, which becomes particularly important when birth parents remain involved and conflict continues.

There are limits. A special guardian cannot change a child’s surname on their own and cannot take the child out of the UK for more than three months without consent or the court’s permission. The order does, however, allow travel abroad for up to three months without the need to obtain consent from others who hold parental responsibility.

The Welfare Checklist: The Court’s Central Test

When deciding whether to make a Special Guardianship Order, the court’s paramount consideration is always the child’s welfare. Section 1 of the Children Act 1989 sets out the welfare checklist, which includes the child’s wishes and feelings, their physical, emotional and educational needs, the likely effect of a change in circumstances, their age and background, any harm suffered or risk of harm, the capability of each relevant adult, and the range of powers available to the court.

Special guardianship is not granted because it is easier for adults or because kinship care is automatically preferred. The legal question is whether the order best promotes the welfare of the individual child, taking the whole picture into account.  The child’s voice matters, but it must be considered alongside every other relevant factor.

Special Guardianship Support: What Help May Be Available

Special guardianship does not operate in isolation. The Special Guardianship Regulations 2005 and the relevant statutory guidance provide a framework for assessment and support, including financial assistance, therapeutic help, contact support and practical help linked to the child’s needs.

For many kinship carers, financial support is a pressing issue. Regular allowances may be means-tested, but local authorities can also provide one-off or case-specific payments for things such as accommodation, furniture, equipment, home adaptations or travel connected to family contact.   These are often the practical issues that determine whether a placement can work well over time. There can also be support in other forms.  Where the special guardian was previously the child’s foster carer, a local authority may continue foster-carer remuneration for two years, and in some cases longer. In England, children who were in care before an SGO was made may also be eligible for therapeutic help through the Adoption and Special Guardianship Support Fund.

Special Guardianship Should Be Strongly Evidenced, Not Rushed

An SGO is intended to provide long-term security.  For that reason, it should only be made on a proper evidential basis. In Re P-S (Children) [2018] EWCA Civ 1407, the Court of Appeal made clear that there is no fixed statutory minimum period a child must live with a proposed special guardian before an order can be made.

That does not mean the court should move too quickly.  The case also makes clear that a final Special Guardianship Order should not be made before there is enough evidence to show that the placement is appropriate and sustainable. Where the position is still uncertain, the better course may be to gather further evidence, adjourn the final decision or use interim arrangements while the placement is assessed more fully.

Mediation and ADR: Why Non-Court Resolution Matters More

The wider litigation landscape has also changed. In Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council [2023] EWCA Civ 1416, the Court of Appeal confirmed that courts can lawfully stay proceedings for, or order parties to engage in, non-court-based dispute resolution where that step is proportionate and does not interfere with the right to a fair hearing.

That does not mean mediation is suitable in every dispute. It does, however, mean that parties should treat non-court dispute resolution as a serious part of the process rather than an afterthought.  In kinship and special guardianship disputes, especially those involving contact or day-to-day practical disputes, courts are working in an environment that is more willing to expect parties to explore ADR before full litigation continues.

Is Special Guardianship Better Than Adoption?

This question needs a measured answer. Current government evidence does not support a blanket claim that special guardianship is better than adoption in every case. The Department for Education’s 2025 Family Routes report found that both routes are usually stable, although adoption showed higher stability on the specific measure of return to care.

A more accurate conclusion is that special guardianship is a strong permanence option alongside adoption, not a universally better one. Its advantages are most apparent where preserving family ties, supporting kinship care, maintaining cultural or personal identity, or avoiding the full legal severance of adoption better serve the child’s welfare.

Conclusion

Special guardianship is one of the most important legal tools available in kinship care. It offers permanence, enhanced parental responsibility and greater decision-making authority than many other family law orders, while still preserving the child’s legal connection to their birth family.

It should not be described as automatically better than adoption. Nor should it be treated as a shortcut to permanence. It is a separate legal framework with its own strengths, limits and support structure. When used in the right manner, it can give a child legal security while also preserving continuity of identity, and these two factors often matter greatly in welfare decisions and in everyday family life.

Key Takeaways 

  • A Special Guardianship Order gives a kinship carer enhanced parental responsibility.
  • An SGO can preserve family links while still providing long-term legal security.
  • Local authority support may include financial help, therapeutic support and contact-related assistance.
  • Courts decide SGO matters by applying the child welfare principle and the welfare checklist.
  • Special guardianship can be a strong alternative to adoption in some cases, but it is not always the better outcome.

FAQ

What is a Special Guardianship Order?

A Special Guardianship Order is a court order that gives a person, often a relative or family friend, enhanced parental responsibility for a child. It is intended to provide more permanence than fostering without creating the full legal break from the birth family that adoption involves.

Does special guardianship remove parental responsibility from birth parents?

Usually no. Birth parents may still hold parental responsibility, but a special guardian can generally exercise their parental responsibility to the exclusion of others, apart from another special guardian.

Can a special guardian change a child’s surname?

Not without consent or the court’s permission. Even with enhanced parental responsibility, a special guardian cannot change a child’s surname unilaterally.

Can a special guardian take a child abroad?

Yes, a special guardian can take a child out of the UK for up to three months without needing further consent. A longer period will usually require consent from others who hold parental responsibility or the court’s permission.

Is special guardianship better than adoption?

Not in every case. Both adoption and special guardianship can provide long-term stability, but they serve different legal and family needs. Special guardianship may be more suitable where maintaining legal and family ties is important.

How We Can Help

At Blanchards Bailey, our specialist Family Law team advises parents, grandparents, relatives and kinship carers on Special Guardianship Orders, parental responsibility, child arrangements and related family law matters. If you seek professional legal help on child guardianship, please contact Julie Keogh: 


Telephone: 01258 488210
Email: julie.keogh@blanchardsbailey.co.uk

Locations: Blandford, Dorchester, Weymouth

Please also visit the Family Law webpage on our website for more information. 

Julie is a Legal 500-ranked solicitor, specialising in matters concerning children, relocation disputes, special guardianship, adoption, child abduction, injunctions, divorce and financial matters arising from divorce and civil partnership.  View Julie's verified client reviews on ReviewSolicitors.  

Blanchards Bailey

So, how can we help?

Whatever your requirements, our team is standing by.

Call us today on
01258 459361