Could Early Binding Contracts Reduce Gazumping and Gazundering?

By Matt Collis, Partner, Residential Property

For decades, buyers and sellers in England and Wales have faced the same frustrating reality: an accepted offer does not create a legally binding commitment. Until contracts are formally exchanged, either party can walk away, accept a higher offer, or attempt to renegotiate the price.  

This is the environment in which gazumping and gazundering continue to occur. Both practices can cause significant financial loss, stress and delays.

The Government has set out plans to introduce binding conditional contracts at an earlier stage of the transaction process, as part of a wider programme of home-buying reforms. The aim is to modernise the conveyancing process, reduce fall-through rates and improve certainty for buyers and sellers.

What are gazumping and gazundering? 
 

Gazumping occurs when a seller has accepted an offer from a buyer but, before contracts are exchanged, accepts another offer (often a higher one) from another buyer or asks the original buyer to increase their offer. 

Because property transactions in England and Wales are generally not legally binding until exchange of contracts, the original buyer can lose the property despite having spent money on searches, surveys, mortgage arrangements and legal work. 

Research reported by the HomeOwners Alliance, based on Market Financial Solutions’ research, found that 37% of surveyed homebuyers had experienced gazumping and that 59% of those affected lost money.

Gazundering is the reverse situation.   A buyer reduces their offer shortly before exchange of contracts, often when the seller is already committed to an onward purchase or other moving arrangements. The seller must then decide whether to accept the reduced offer, renegotiate, or risk the transaction collapsing. 

Research cited by Santander (based on Zoopla data using Open Property Group research) suggests that around one in four sellers experienced gazundering over a 12-month period.

Both practices are possible because an accepted offer is generally not legally binding in England and Wales until contracts are exchanged. The wider consequences of failed transactions can be significant, with Santander estimating that failed property transactions cost consumers around £560 million each year in fees and expenses.

What are Binding Conditional Contracts? 

The Government's reform roadmap includes proposals for binding conditional contracts that would be entered into earlier in the transaction. While the detailed framework has yet to be implemented, the principle is that once a buyer and seller have agreed terms, both parties would make a formal commitment to proceed, subject to agreed conditions such as satisfactory surveys, mortgage approval or title investigations.

The Government intends to develop a framework under which parties who withdraw without a permitted reason could face financial consequences, subject to future legislation. This would represent a significant departure from the current system, where offers generally remain non-binding until exchange of contracts.

Could Binding Conditional Contracts Reduce Gazumping and Gazundering? 

The reforms are intended to reduce the incidence of both gazumping and gazundering.

A seller who has entered into a binding conditional contract would generally no longer be able to accept a higher offer from another buyer without potentially breaching their obligations. Equally, a buyer could face consequences for attempting to renegotiate the price at the last minute without legitimate grounds.

By introducing commitment earlier in the process, the Government hopes to give buyers and sellers greater confidence once terms have been agreed. Consultation responses have also highlighted support for measures designed to provide greater certainty and reduce the risk of transactions falling through.

The Potential Benefits for Buyers and Sellers

For buyers and sellers, the advantages could be substantial:

  • greater certainty once an offer has been accepted;
  • fewer transactions collapsing late in the process;
  • reduced wasted expenditure on surveys, searches and legal fees;
  • lower levels of stress and uncertainty.

The Government's wider reform package is intended to reduce costs and help lower the number of failed property transactions.

Challenges Still Remain

While early binding contracts may reduce opportunistic behaviour, they are unlikely to eliminate all transaction failures. Genuine issues can still arise, including adverse survey findings, mortgage difficulties, title defects or problems elsewhere in the chain.

The success of the reforms will depend on how the conditions, exceptions and financial consequences are ultimately drafted and implemented. There will also need to be sufficient upfront information available so that buyers can make informed decisions before committing.

The Government's proposals also include sales packs containing key property information, alongside digital property logbooks as part of its plans to modernise the conveyancing process.

What This Could Mean for Conveyancing

The proposed introduction of binding conditional contracts represents a potentially significant change to the residential conveyancing process. While it may not completely eliminate gazumping and gazundering, it has the potential to make these practices less common and provide greater certainty for buyers and sellers.

These proposals relate primarily to England and Wales, where the current conveyancing process differs from the system used in Scotland. 

As the reforms develop, conveyancers will continue to play an important role in helping clients understand their rights, obligations and the implications of earlier legal commitments. For anyone buying or selling property, obtaining specialist legal advice at the earliest opportunity will remain crucial.

How We Can Help

At Blanchards Bailey, our Residential Property team helps buyers and sellers understand their legal position throughout the conveyancing process.  We advise on searches, title issues and the practical implications of proposed changes to the home-buying process.  

If you are buying or selling a property and would like to speak with us, please contact Matt Collis on 01747 445664 or request a callback from our Residential Property team.  

You can also visit our Residential Property page on our website for more information, or view Matt's verified client reviews on ReviewSolicitors. 

Frequently Asked Questions

What is gazumping?

Gazumping occurs when a seller has accepted an offer from a buyer but, before contracts are exchanged, accepts another offer (often a higher one) from another buyer or asks the original buyer to increase their offer. Because property transactions in England and Wales are generally not legally binding until exchange of contracts, the original buyer can lose the property despite having spent money on searches, surveys, mortgage arrangements and legal work. Research reported by the HomeOwners Alliance, based on Market Financial Solutions’ research, found that 37% of surveyed homebuyers had experienced gazumping and that 59% of those affected lost money.

What is gazundering?

Gazundering is the reverse situation, a buyer reduces their offer shortly before exchange of contracts, often when the seller is already committed to an onwards purchase or other moving arrangements. The seller must then decide whether to accept the reduced offer, renegotiate, or risk the transaction collapsing. Research cited by Santander, based on Zoopla data using Open Property Group research, suggests that around one in four sellers experienced gazundering over a 12-month period.

Both practices are possible because an accepted offer is generally not legally binding in England and Wales until contracts are exchanged. The wider consequences of failed transactions can be significant, Santander estimates that failed property transactions cost consumers around £560 million each year in fees and expenses.

What are binding conditional contracts?

Binding conditional contracts are proposed contracts that would create a formal commitment between buyer and seller earlier in the transaction, subject to agreed conditions such as surveys, mortgage approval or title investigations.

Would early binding contracts stop gazumping and gazundering completely?

Not necessarily. They may reduce opportunistic behaviour, but genuine issues such as survey problems, mortgage difficulties, title defects or chain-related issues could still cause transactions to fail.

Blanchards Bailey

So, how can we help?

Whatever your requirements, our team is standing by.

Call us today on
01258 459361