Your Diagnosis, Your Decision: Dementia, Wills, and the Right to Have Your Wishes Heard

By Charlotte Parsons, Senior Associate, Private Client Services 

The phone call came on a Tuesday. Barbara’s daughter had just driven her mother home from the memory clinic when the questions started — not about care packages or medication, but about the future. 

“Mum, have you got a Will?” 

It is a conversation playing out in households across the country, more often than any of us might expect. Nearly one million people in the UK are currently estimated to be living with dementia, a figure projected to rise to 1.4 million by 2040 (source: Alzheimer’s Society). For many of them, and for the families gathering around them, estate planning can feel either too frightening to approach or, worse, already out of reach.

It isn’t. Not yet, and sometimes not at all.

Can Someone Make a Will after a Dementia Diagnosis?

The most damaging myth circulating on forums, in family kitchens, and even in some legal consultations is this: that a dementia diagnosis automatically prevents someone from making a valid Will. It does not. 

Under English law, making a Will requires what lawyers call testamentary capacity.  This is a legal standard, not a medical one.  The important question is whether the person has the required understanding at the time the Will is made.

A person must understand what a Will is and the effect it will have; know, in broad terms, the extent of what they own; recognise the people who might reasonably expect to benefit from their estate (such as family members or dependants); communicate their wishes clearly, and be able to make those decisions without their thinking being impaired in a way that affects the terms of the Will. 

Separate issues, such as undue influencer or whether the person knew and approved the contents of the Will, may also affect validity. 

Why Dementia Does Not Automatically Remove Testamentary Capacity

Dementia does not erase those abilities overnight. It affects individuals in profoundly different ways. Someone in the early stages may remain fully capable of clear, considered decision-making. Others experience “lucid intervals” — periods of greater clarity during which a valid Will can still be made, provided the legal requirements are met at the time.   

Capacity, specialist lawyers emphasise, is both decision-specific and time-specific. The same person might struggle to manage their online banking on a Tuesday and still be entirely capable of instructing a lawyer on a Wednesday morning. Lawyers will therefore assess whether an individual has met these criteria at the time the Will is made.  In some cases, particularly where there is a dementia diagnosis, lawyers may recommend a medical opinion to support the assessment and reduce the risk of the Will being challenged later. 

"Capacity is not a light switch. It can vary from person to person, and from day to day." 

What Happens if Your Executor has Dementia? 

There is, though, a dimension of this issue that receives far less attention: what happens when it is not the person making the Will who has dementia, but the person named to carry it out? 

Executors, those appointed to administer an estate after death, are often chosen in mid-life and never revisited. A trusted sibling named at 55 may be living with early-stage Alzheimer’s by the time they are called upon to act. An executor who lacks the mental capacity required to administer the estate cannot act while that incapacity lasts. They cannot apply for the Grant of Probate, manage estate assets, liaise with HMRC, or distribute funds to beneficiaries.

The legal system has mechanisms for this, but these routes are rarely as straightforward as choosing the right executors in the first place.  They take time and money, and they require someone in a grieving family to identify the problem and act. 

Will disputes and probate caveats have increased in England and Wales in recent years, and concerns about capacity are a common feature in disputed estates, particularly where a Will was made later in life or after a diagnosis of dementia. 

The solution is straightforward, if rarely acted upon - review your Will regularly. Check who you have named as executor. Consider whether they are still the right person — in health, in circumstance, in relationship to you.

When Should You Seek Legal Advice After a Dementia Diagnosis?

If you or someone you love has received a diagnosis, the priority is to seek specialist legal advice without delay. An experienced lawyer who specialises in Private Client law can assess capacity appropriately, ensure the Will reflects genuine intentions, put safeguards in place to minimise the risk of disputes, and arrange for an independent medical opinion where needed. That last step — sometimes called the “golden rule” — is not legally required, but it is increasingly considered best practice. A formal capacity assessment, taken at the time the will is signed, creates a contemporaneous record that can make a later challenge more difficult.

Why You Should Tell Your Lawyer about a Dementia Diagnosis

There is one thing, above all, that lawyers urge their clients to do: be honest. 

Do not hide a diagnosis from your lawyer. Transparency is not a vulnerability; it is a protection. Sharing the information allows the right steps to be taken, at the right time, to help make your Will as robust as possible. Trying to avoid the issue, by contrast, can create exactly the problems it was meant to prevent: a document that is challenged after death, a family left in dispute, and wishes that go unheard.

Barbara, for what it’s worth, did make her Will six weeks after her diagnosis, on a bright spring morning when, as her daughter recalled, “she was completely herself.” It has never been questioned. Her wishes are on record. 

As Dementia Action Week approaches, that is the story worth telling: a diagnosis is not the end of agency. But it is, perhaps, the most important prompt you will ever receive to use it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a person with dementia make a valid Will?

Yes. A dementia diagnosis does not automatically prevent someone from making a valid Will. The key issue is whether the person has testamentary capacity at the time the Will is made.

What is testamentary capacity?

Testamentary capacity is the legal ability to make a Will. In broad terms, the person must understand the nature and effect of making a Will, know the extent of their estate, recognise who might reasonably expect to benefit, and make decisions without their thinking being impaired in a way that affects the Will.

Should I tell my lawyer about a dementia diagnosis?

Yes. Telling your lawyer allows them to put the right safeguards in place, such as a careful capacity assessment or an independent medical opinion where appropriate. This can help reduce the risk of the Will being challenged later.

What is the golden rule in Will-making?

The golden rule is a recognised safeguard often used where someone is elderly, seriously ill, or has a condition such as dementia. It usually involves obtaining a medical opinion on capacity at or around the time the Will is made. It is not a strict legal requirement, but it can provide important evidence if the Will is later questioned.

What happens if an executor develops dementia?

If an executor lacks the mental capacity required to administer the estate, they cannot act while that incapacity lasts. Co-executors, substitute executors, attorneys, professionals, or a court-appointed administrator may need to become involved, depending on the circumstances.

How often should I review my Will?

It is sensible to review your Will regularly, especially after major life changes, a diagnosis affecting capacity, the death or illness of an executor, changes in family circumstances, or significant changes to your assets.

How We Can Help

If you or a loved one has received a dementia diagnosis and would like to make or review a Will, our specialist Private Client Services team can help you take the right steps with care, sensitivity and legal precision.

Contact Charlotte Parsons or her team to discuss your circumstances in confidence.

Telephone: 01258 459361

Email: EP@blanchardsbailey.co.uk

Locations: Blandford, Dorchester, Shaftesbury, Weymouth

Blanchards Bailey

So, how can we help?

Whatever your requirements, our team is standing by.

Call us today on
01258 459361