By Nicola Mitchell-Rodd, Senior Associate, Contentious Probate and Trusts and Laura Martin, Partner, Head of Family Law.
Divorce proceedings are rarely straightforward, but matters can become particularly complex if one party dies before financial claims have been resolved. When this happens, issues which began in the family courts can quickly move into the realm of contentious probate with disputes often arising between the surviving spouse and other beneficiaries or family members who may feel that the surviving spouse should not benefit due to the marriage having broken down before death.
The Legal Status of Your Marriage
In England and Wales, a marriage legally ends only when a Final Order is granted in divorce proceedings. If one spouse dies before that stage, the parties remain legally married. This can have significant consequences for inheritance, as the surviving spouse may still be entitled to benefit from the deceased’s estate under a will or intestacy rules, even where the couple had already separated.
Crucial Note: The pronouncement of the Final Order in the divorce proceedings legally ends the marriage, but it does not legally end the financial claims arising from the marriage and divorce. The only way to finalise such claims is to obtain a Financial Remedy Order within the divorce proceedings – this is separate to the divorce but intrinsically linked.
Claims After Death: The 1975 Act
Where financial remedy proceedings are ongoing but not concluded at the time of death, the family court process will usually come to an end as financial divorce claims cannot be pursued after death. However, this does not necessarily mean financial claims disappear.
A surviving spouse or dependant may still be able to bring a claim against the estate under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975.
2026 Case Study: Kars v Brown & Ors [2026] EWHC 31 (Fam)
In the recently reported case of Kars v Brown & Ors, the High Court considered a claim under the 1975 Act brought by Ms Kars, against her former husband’s estate.
- The Conflict: The couple divorced in 2019 after an 18-year marriage, but their financial remedy proceedings had not been finalised when the deceased died in 2021. The deceased died without a Will, and because they were divorced, his estate bypassed Ms Kars under the intestacy rules, meaning she wouldn’t have received anything.
- The Argument: Ms Kars argued that because the deceased died before their matrimonial finances had been resolved, his estate failed to make financial provision for her and had the financial remedy proceedings been concluded before death, she would have received provision from the matrimonial pot.
- The Ruling: The Court agreed and ordered that the deceased’s 50% share of their joint home be transferred to Ms Kars, making her the sole owner.
Summary and Key Takeaways
This case illustrates how closely family law and probate can overlap. For separating couples, reviewing Wills and seeking legal advice during divorce proceedings can be an important step in reducing uncertainty should circumstances change unexpectedly. It is vital that the matrimonial finances are properly dealt with on divorce and legal advice should be sought early on.
Where divorce proceedings were ongoing at the time of death, executors and/or beneficiaries may need to navigate both family law and contentious probate issues.
How We Can Help
Contentious Trusts and Probate
Nicola Mitchell-Rodd, Senior Associate
Telephone: 01258 444814
Email: nicola.mitchell-rodd@blanchardsbailey.co.uk
Locations: Blandford, Dorchester, Weymouth and Shaftsbury
Family, Divorce and Separation
Laura Martin, Partner and Head of Family Law
Telephone: 01258 488216
Email: laura.martin@blanchardsbailey.co.uk
Locations: Blandford, Dorchester, Weymouth and Shaftsbury
Family Legal Clinic in Weymouth: Book now
You can also visit the Contentious Trusts and Probate webpage and the Family Law webpage on our website for more information.
So, how can we help?
Whatever your requirements, our team is standing by.
Call us today on
01258 459361