Contesting a Will: What Does It Actually Mean?

By Lucy Mignot, Partner and Head of Contentious Trusts and Probate

Many clients contact us because they want to contest a Will. The reason for making that initial call varies.  They may be concerned about how the will was made, who was involved, whether it truly reflects the wishes of the person who made it, or whether the person understood what they were doing at the time. Or perhaps they believe that the way the estate is distributed according to the Will is not right.

Whatever the trigger, clients are often unsure what contesting a Will actually involves.  

Put simply, contesting a Will usually means one of two things:

  1. Challenging the validity of the Will; or
  2. Asking the court to alter the way an estate is distributed.

These are very different types of claims.

Challenging the Validity of a Will

A Will must meet certain legal requirements to be valid. If there is evidence that any of those have not been met, it may be possible to challenge the Will.

Common Grounds

  • Lack of testamentary capacity – the person making the Will did not have the required mental capacity.
  • Undue influence – someone pressured or coerced the person into making the Will in a way that does not reflect their true wishes.
  • Lack of knowledge and approval – the person signing the Will did not understand or approve the contents of the document.
  • Improper execution – the Will was not signed and witnessed correctly.
  • Fraud or forgery – in rare cases, the Will itself may not be genuine.

The Outcome: If a challenge of this type succeeds, the Will is declared invalid. The estate will then be distributed either in accordance with the previous valid Will, or under the intestacy rules if no earlier Will exists.

Claims for Reasonable Financial Provision 

In some cases, the issue is not whether the Will is valid, but whether it makes adequate provision for certain people.

Under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975, certain categories of individuals, including spouses, former spouses, cohabitees, children and dependants, may be able to bring a claim if the Will (or intestacy) does not make reasonable financial provision for them.

The Outcome: This type of claim does not invalidate the Will. Instead, the court has the power to order that part of the estate be redistributed to ensure a reasonable provision is made.

What Happens in Practice When Someone Wants to Contest a Will?

Evidence is key.  If the validity of the Will is in question, information is needed about the circumstances in which the Will was prepared and executed. This can include obtaining the solicitor’s or will writer’s will file, reviewing medical records and speaking to witnesses.

In a claim for financial provision, evidence is required about the key factors that the court will take into account when deciding whether to alter the distribution of the estate. Often this means: 

  • Information about the financial position of those bringing the claim and the beneficiaries under the Will.
  •  The size and nature of the estate.
  •  Disabilities, and any particular obligations or responsibilities the person owed to others.

The Resolution Process: At this stage, we will assess whether there are realistic grounds for a claim. 

Most inheritance disputes are resolved through negotiation or mediation rather than court proceedings so, if the evidence supports a claim, this is normally the next stage. In most cases, only when attempts to reach a settlement have failed will it be necessary to involve the court.

Critical Timing: When Should Advice Be Taken?

Timing can be critical in disputes about Wills, so it is important to seek legal advice as early as possible.  Early advice can help establish what steps should be taken to protect a potential interest in the estate and to ensure that crucial time limits are not missed.

How We Can Help

If you have concerns about an estate or trust, our specialist Contentious Trusts and Probate team is here to provide the support you need.  Contact Lucy Mignot or her team: 

Telephone: 01305 217303

Email: lucy.mignot@blanchardsbailey.co.uk 

Locations: Dorchester, Weymouth, Blandford, Shaftesbury 

You can also visit the Contentious Probate webpage on our website for more information. 

Blanchards Bailey

So, how can we help?

Whatever your requirements, our team is standing by.

Call us today on
01258 459361